2007-03-23: Pradigm Shift: Convergence and Tipping Point?
From Datafedwiki
Back to DataFed Development Events
Contents |
[edit] Concepts in Dynamics Systems
[edit] Pradigm Shift
Thomas Kuhn's concept of "paradigm shift" was a way of explaining how in occasianally there are majors shifts that change the basic assumptions within the ruling theory of science. However, the reasons why a scientific pardigm is shifted are not explained.
[edit] Inflection Point; Tipping Point
In the business domain a similar concept called inflection point was introduced by Andy Grove of Intel. "There is a strategic inflection points in the life of a business when its fundamentals are about to change. That change can mean an opportunity to rise to new heights….but it may just as likely signal the beginning of the end."Tipping Point occurs in a dynamic process beyond which the rate of the process increases dramatically. Tipping point has been applied in economics to epidemiology. It can also be compared to phase transition in physics or the propagation of populations in an unbalanced ecosystem. In control theory, it corresponds to a transition from negative to positive feedback.
[edit] Convergence
Convergence is now used to "explain" many new developments in natural, social and information sciences. The mathematical meaning (convergent series, congerging graphs etc) is clear but the expaded current usage is less so. Digital Convergence for example means convergence of digital technologies as the dominant way of representing, storing, and communicating information (commputer, communication,...).
- Natural Systems
- IT systems...
[edit] Paradigm Shift: Convergence Followed by Tipping Point?
In the current usage of the terms, a paradigm shift could be described as a process where convergence of relevant influencing factors leads to a tipping point in the system that changes its fundamental characteristics. (Huh, what a paradigm soup :))
To me, the key here is that the phenomenon paradigm shift is now broken into two explantory processes in sequence: simultaneous chages (toward each other) of multiple factors that then cause a 'tipping point' to occur ... After the tipping point, the paradigm is shifted.
[edit] Stove Pipes to Networks: A Paradigm Shift?
I think that going from 'stove pipe' the 'networked' infromation systems is a paradigm shift. It is occuring as a consequence of the triple convergence of
- Flattenrs coverged
- Infrastructure ready
- New sensors, info sources
The tipping point will take place when we starting to reap benefits of the network network effect.
- Stovepipes are designed informations systems that deliver specified services.
- Service Oriented Architecture (SAO) promotes connection of loosely connected reusable components
SAO is like a Sos http://www.stsc.hill.af.mil/Crosstalk/2007/10/0710ValerdiRossRhodes.html
Delicious/rhusar/SystemOfSystems
- rhusar's SystemOfSystems Bookmarks on Delicious
For Erin, Literature on SoS - Programmatic Interoperability
Interoperability has traditionally been considered a property of operational systems, where systems are able to exchange information in some agreed-upon fashion. However, other aspects of interoperability are often overlooked. This report introduces one of those aspects—the concept of programmatic interoperability, which is the application of principles of interoperability to the acquisition management of systems. It shows how programmatic interoperability contributes to fielding interoperable capabilities and relates this aspect to current trends such as network-centric operations. The report also discusses the orchestration of decisions and activities that are applicable to acquisition in a system-of-systems environment. Finally, the report suggests several research topics. - SoS Navigator 2.0: A Context-Based Approach to System-of-Systems Challenges
The SoS Navigator approach provides leaders participating in complex systems of systems with (1) novel insights into critical aspects of the demand and supply sides of their situation and (2) criteria on which to decide whether their systems-of-systems context requires the adoption and sustainment of a different business model than ones that are typical today. This technical note introduces the fundamental concepts, processes, and techniques of the evolving SoS Navigator approach. It also summarizes case studies that illustrate the use of SoS Navigator processes and tools in healthcare, military, and civilian government systems-of-systems contexts. - System-of-Systems Navigator: An Approach for Managing System-of-Systems Interoperability
Large software systems are now constructed as groups of interoperating systems (as systems of systems) developed by different but sometimes related teams and made to interoperate through various forms of interfaces. Unfortunately, we have trouble building them. Software engineering practices have not kept pace, and the problem will only get worse as the community begins to build Internet-scale systems of systems like the Global Information Grid. This note introduces the System-of-Systems Navigator (SoS Navigator), the collection and codification of essential practices for building large-scale systems of systems. which provides tools and techniques to characterize organizational, technical, and operational enablers and barriers to success in a system of systems; identify improvement strategies; and pilot and institutionalize these strategies. - Maier: Architecting Principles for Systems-of-Systems
While there is growing recognition of the importance of “Systems-of-systems,” there is little agreement on just what they are or on by what principles they should be constructed. This paper proposes a taxonomy of these super-systems and exhibits a basic set of architecting principles to assist in their design. While several heuristics are particularly applicable to systems-of-systems, the key insight is the central role played by communication standards. The enabling architecture of systems-of-systems is non-physical, it is set of standards that allow meaningful communication among the components. This is illustrated through existing and proposed systems. - Topics in Interoperability: Infrastructure Replacement in a System of Systems
- Tien: Services: A System's Perspective
a service system is an integrated system, it is, in essence, a system-of-systems (SoS) which objectives are to enhance its efficiency (leading to greater interdependency), effectiveness (leading to greater usefulness), and adaptiveness (leading to greater - De Laurentis: A Case for an International Consortium on System-of-Systems Engineering
The consortium could lead efforts in clarifying ambiguities and in seeking remedies to numerous open questions with respect to SoS analysis, SoS engineering (SoSE), as well as differences between systems engineering (SE) and SoSE - System-of-Systems Governance: New Patterns of Thought
Systems of systems introduce complications for information technology (IT) governance because their individual system components exhibit considerable autonomy. The SoS characteristics discussed are (1) collaboration and authority, (2) motivation and accountability, (3) multiple models, (4) expectation of evolution, (5) highly fluid processes, and (6) minimal centrality. When systems cross organizational boundaries, the development problems—and, by extension, IT governance problems—are multi-plied due to conflicting structures, policies, and expectations. - Meilich07: Architecture Challenges in a Net Centric Environment
- SoS Summer Conversation report.pdf (application/pdf Object)
- Meilich08: Control Systems, How Cognitive and Social Domains Influence Decision Making
- IEEE SoSE07: International Conference on System of Systems Engineering.
- 01652264.pdf (application/pdf Object)
- Meilich: Humans-In-The-Loop - Challenges in a Complex SoS Environment
Rhusar 17:00, 23 March 2007 (CST)
Categories: DevEvents | Atomic | Yymmdd | SoS
